Comments on: I Am Legend Alternate Ending Makes Me Want To Grenade Myself! http://filmonic.com/i-am-legend-alternate-ending-makes-me-want-to-grenade-myself Molesting Your Film Shaft! Sat, 21 Nov 2009 15:39:47 -0800 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.6 hourly 1 By: Taylorhttp://filmonic.com/i-am-legend-alternate-ending-makes-me-want-to-grenade-myself/comment-page-1#comment-5064 Taylor Sun, 07 Dec 2008 07:51:24 +0000 http://filmonic.com/i-am-legend-alternate-ending-makes-me-want-to-grenade-myself#comment-5064 John, maybe if you really read what he was saying up there. The ending would have been illogical. Just like he said, the filmmakers made it seem that the entire film was about the alpha male trying to kill Nevile...not to try and find his "love." The character they had convinced us is a psychotic killing machine suddenly finds a heart out of nowhere? It's not to say that it's a stupid ending at all. In fact, I'm sure the book made that kind of ending understandable. But something tells me that the filmmakers skipped over the more thought-provoking sides of the book and stuck with the action-y parts, therefore making the gut-wrenching ending kind of moot. And for the love of God, stop sounding like one of those elitists who always has to spew out something to the extent of "well, simple minds like yours couldn't possibly grasp something to profound." Yeah, we could. The alpha leader had been searching for his love, the same "zombie" that Neville had taken; that was the entire reason for the main attack. Not that hard to grasp...just kind of pointless when they were going for an action film. John, maybe if you really read what he was saying up there. The ending would have been illogical. Just like he said, the filmmakers made it seem that the entire film was about the alpha male trying to kill Nevile…not to try and find his "love." The character they had convinced us is a psychotic killing machine suddenly finds a heart out of nowhere?

It's not to say that it's a stupid ending at all. In fact, I'm sure the book made that kind of ending understandable. But something tells me that the filmmakers skipped over the more thought-provoking sides of the book and stuck with the action-y parts, therefore making the gut-wrenching ending kind of moot.

And for the love of God, stop sounding like one of those elitists who always has to spew out something to the extent of "well, simple minds like yours couldn't possibly grasp something to profound." Yeah, we could. The alpha leader had been searching for his love, the same "zombie" that Neville had taken; that was the entire reason for the main attack. Not that hard to grasp…just kind of pointless when they were going for an action film.

]]> By: Johnhttp://filmonic.com/i-am-legend-alternate-ending-makes-me-want-to-grenade-myself/comment-page-1#comment-3338 John Thu, 09 Oct 2008 12:26:11 +0000 http://filmonic.com/i-am-legend-alternate-ending-makes-me-want-to-grenade-myself#comment-3338 I suggest you read the book before making statements about the movie and its endings. The alternate ending is actually closer to the books ending then the original ending. But, minds like yours would not understand it, so that is why they chose the one they did. People don't want to understand a movie, they just want to watch it. That defeats the whole point of a 'story'. Read the book before you pass judgement. If you can't understand it, ask someone who does and they will explain it to you. I suggest you read the book before making statements about the movie and its endings. The alternate ending is actually closer to the books ending then the original ending. But, minds like yours would not understand it, so that is why they chose the one they did. People don’t want to understand a movie, they just want to watch it. That defeats the whole point of a ’story’. Read the book before you pass judgement. If you can’t understand it, ask someone who does and they will explain it to you.

]]> By: Sukihttp://filmonic.com/i-am-legend-alternate-ending-makes-me-want-to-grenade-myself/comment-page-1#comment-9032 Suki Mon, 28 Jul 2008 14:44:33 +0000 http://filmonic.com/i-am-legend-alternate-ending-makes-me-want-to-grenade-myself#comment-9032 That was the point of the book though, it ends with Neville ALIVE, he becomes the 'legend' , the myth that once was vampires is now him. The entire reason the book is titled 'I Am Legend' !!! That was the point of the book though, it ends with Neville ALIVE, he becomes the 'legend' , the myth that once was vampires is now him. The entire reason the book is titled 'I Am Legend' !!!

]]>